In yesterday’s post, China Employee Terminations and The New Two Child Policy, I discussed how the laws vary in China regarding whether an employer can terminate an employee for having violated China’s family planning laws. In this post, I address whether an employee’s violating China’s family planning laws allows the employer to refuse to provide the extra protections normally provided employees during pregnancy, such as no overtime or an adjustment of workload?
As is nearly always the case with any China labor law issues, the answer varies by locale, but generally speaking, a pregnant/nursing employee who violates China’s family planning laws should be treated the same as other pregnant/nursing employees while on the job. However, other benefits after childbirth, such as paid maternity leave can generally be withheld from an employee who has violated the family planning laws, though this too varies by location.
I should emphasize how important it is not to try to remove an employee’s legal protections by having them sign a contract that purports to do so. A fairly recent case out of Shanghai (a fairly employer friendly city) makes this clear.
In this case, an employee entered into an employment contract with her Employer on her first day: March 1. This employee was required to fill out an employee form before she officially started. As she was not married at that time, she checked the box for “single” on the form. The Contract expressly provided that if any information provided by the employee was untrue, the employer would have the right to void the contract and unilaterally terminate the employee. The employer’s handbook contained similar provisions and also required its employees update the employer within 10 days if any personal information, such as marital status had changed. The Employee became pregnant a few days after her first day and started going to checkups but she never informed her employer about her pregnancy until October.
The Employee married in May and her employer approved her marriage leave. A couple of months before her expected due date, the employee provided her employer with a doctor’s note saying she would need to go on maternity leave because she would need to rest before her scheduled C-section. The employee requested paid maternity leave, but her employer immediately terminated her because she had “deceived” them by not providing accurate information about her personal situation. The employer then brought a labor arbitration claim against the employee seeking to declare her employment contract void. The employee filed counterclaims demanding her salary during her sick leave and maternity leave, as well as double statutory severance for unlawful termination and reinstatement of her position.
The employer lost on most of the claims and was ordered to pay the employee her salary during her sick days and during her maternity leave and also to pay for her social insurance until the last day of her extended maternity leave. The court acknowledged that the employee should have updated her employer on her marital/pregnancy status sooner, however, nothing she had done justified her unilateral termination. The labor arbitration committee did not discuss the employee’s claim for double statutory severance for unlawful termination and because the employee withdrew her claim for reinstatement of her position and did not argue for unlawful termination severance at the court level the court did not discuss those claims either.
The court stated in its first sentence of its decision that “employees’ legal interests are protected by law” and female workers “giving birth is a natural and legal right and must be accorded full protection.” Though this case was decided before China’s new two-child policy and though some of the legal aspects of this case have changed, what has not changed is that it is simply not possible to remove most worker protections via contract. Most importantly, what also has not changed is the importance that you as a China employer should know and follow all of the relevant laws and regulations and rules (national, regional, and local down to your specific district within your city) before terminating or even penalizing one of your employees.This article was written by Grace Yang and published on China Law Blog. Original Post: http://www.chinalawblog.com/2016/11/china-employment-laws-in-the-two-child-era.html